Meetings
P-04-329 Control of noise nuisance from wind turbines
This page gives details of any meetings held which will, or did, discuss the matter, and includes links to the relevant Papers, Agendas and Minutes.
Note: Meeting Agenda can change at short notice. Particularly where future meeting dates are indicated more than a week in advance. Please check before planning to attend a Committee Meeting that the item you are interested in has not been moved.
Meeting: 17/07/2012 - Petitions Committee - Fourth Assembly (Item 5)
5 P-04-329 Control of Noise nuisance from Wind Turbines
Supporting documents:
Meeting: 11/07/2012 - Plenary - Fourth Assembly (Item 5.)
Debate on Petitions Committee's Report on Control of Noise from Wind Turbines
NDM5036 William
Powell (Mid and West Wales)
To propose that the National Assembly for Wales:
Notes the report of the Petitions Committee on the Control
of Noise from Wind Turbines, which was laid in the Table Office on 30 May 2012.
Note: The Welsh Government response to the report was laid on 4 July 2012.
Supporting Documents:
Report of the Petitions Committee
Decision:
The item started at 16.38
NDM5036 William
Powell (Mid and West Wales)
To propose that the National Assembly for Wales:
Notes the report of the Petitions Committee on the Control of Noise from Wind Turbines, which was laid in the Table Office on 30 May 2012.
Note: The Welsh Government response to the report was laid on 4 July 2012.
The motion was agreed
in accordance with Standing Order 12.36.
Meeting: 19/06/2012 - Petitions Committee - Fourth Assembly (Item 6)
6 P-04-329 Control of Noise Nuisance from Wind Turbines
Supporting documents:
Meeting: 29/05/2012 - Petitions Committee - Fourth Assembly (Item 6)
P-04-329 Control of noise nuisance from wind turbines
Supporting documents:
- Restricted enclosure 12 , View reasons restricted (6/1)
- Restricted enclosure 13
Minutes:
The Committee agreed the report for publication, subject to several amendments being made to the recommendations.
Meeting: 01/05/2012 - Petitions Committee - Fourth Assembly (Item 2)
2 P-04-329 Control of noise nuisance from wind - discussion of site visits and evidence given on 28 February
Supporting documents:
- PET(4)-05-12 p4a Coversheet, 13/03/2012 Petitions Committee, item 2 PDF 277 KB View as HTML (2/1) 6 KB
- PET(4)-05-12 p4d Winfarms Visits - Note, 13/03/2012 Petitions Committee, item 2 PDF 108 KB
- PET(4)-05-12 p4e Correspondence from Statkraft, 13/03/2012 Petitions Committee, item 2 PDF 1 MB
- 2012.03.08 Stephen Dube - extract from Hanning Report on Wind Turbine Noise, item 2 PDF 227 KB View as HTML (2/4) 48 KB
- 2012.03.08 Stephen Dube - summary of Frey Haddon Report on Noise Radiation from Wind Turbines, item 2 PDF 200 KB View as HTML (2/5) 15 KB
- P-03-329 Grwp Blaengwen e-mail, item 2 PDF 243 KB View as HTML (2/6) 7 KB
- BMJ Article, item 2 PDF 142 KB
- 2012.03.10 Petitioner to Chair, item 2 PDF 178 KB View as HTML (2/8) 7 KB
- 12.04.18 Minister to Chair, item 2 PDF 363 KB
Minutes:
The Committee agreed to produce a short report on the subject of noise from wind turbines and request a Plenary debate.
Meeting: 26/04/2012 - Health and Social Care Committee - Fourth Assembly (Item 3)
3 Petition P-04-329 control of noise from wind turbines
HSC(4)-12-12 paper 6
Supporting documents:
Minutes:
3.5 The Committee noted the paper .
Meeting: 13/03/2012 - Petitions Committee - Fourth Assembly (Item 4)
4 P-04-329 Control of noise nuisance from wind turbines - discussion of site visits and evidence given on 28 February
Supporting documents:
- PET(4)-05-12 p4a Coversheet, item 4 PDF 277 KB View as HTML (4/1) 6 KB
- PET(4)-05-12 p4b Evidence from Campaigner on Noise from Windfarm in Parc Cynog, item 4 PDF 135 KB
- PET(4)-05-12 p4c Evidence from Local Resident, item 4 PDF 258 KB
- PET(4)-05-12 p4d Winfarms Visits - Note, item 4 PDF 108 KB
- PET(4)-05-12 p4e Correspondence from Statkraft, item 4 PDF 1 MB
Minutes:
Given that several of the Members who attended the Committee’s site visits to windfarms in Carmarthenshire were not present at the meeting, the Committee agreed to postpone the item until Members are present and responses to the Committee’s letters on the subject have been received.
Meeting: 28/02/2012 - Petitions Committee - Fourth Assembly (Item 4)
4 P-04-329 Control of noise nuisance from wind - Open-mic Session
Introduction from Grwp Blaengwen Action Group
Stephen Dubé,
Chair of Grwp Blaengwen
Action Group
Bleddyn Williams, Grwp Blaengwen Action Group Member
Caryl Harris, Grwp Blaengwen
Action Group Member
Lynn Morris, Grwp
Blaengwen Action Group Member
Terrence Neil, Grwp Blaengwen Action Group Member
Supporting documents:
- PET(4)-04-12 p12a Coversheet, item 4 PDF 18 KB View as HTML (4/1) 6 KB
- PET(4)-04-12 p12b Correspondence from the Petitioner, item 4 PDF 124 KB
Minutes:
The Committee heard from members of Grwp Blaengwen Action Group and other members of the community.
The Committee agreed:
To write to the Health and Social Care Committee as well as the Environment and Sustainability Committee, summarising the community’s concerns about the impact of noise from wind turbines and enclosing the transcript of the meeting;
To write to Statkraft to outline the Committee’s concerns about the handling of complaints from the local community; to urge them to find a solution to the noise problems experienced by local people; and to request them to hold a formal meeting with Grwp Blaengwen Action Group to discuss the problems experienced;
That individual Committee Members would share the transcript of the open-mic session with other Assembly Members in their political groups;
Write to the Minister for Health and Social Services to make her aware of the community’s concerns about noise from windfarms;
Write to the Minister for Environment and Sustainable Development to make him aware of the community’s concerns about noise from windfarms and about the lack of a review of, and community consultation on, TAN 8;
To make Wales’ four MEPs aware of the key points of the discussion;
To publish a note of the Committee’s meetings with stakeholders on 27 February.
Meeting: 15/11/2011 - Petitions Committee - Fourth Assembly (Item 3)
3 P-04-329 Control of Noise Nuisance from Wind Turbines
Supporting documents:
- PET(04)-06-11 p11a Cover sheet, item 3 PDF 285 KB View as HTML (3/1) 6 KB
- PET(04)-06-11 p11b Correspondence from the MInister for Environment and Sustainable Development, item 3 PDF 287 KB
Minutes:
The Committee agreed to:
Arrange a site visit for Committee Members who wish it;
Forward the evidence received to the Environment and Sustainability Committee for consideration as part of its Inquiry into Energy Policy and Planning in Wales;
Investigate the potential for a joint site visit with the Environment and Sustainability Committee;
Commission a research paper on the subject for future consideration.
Meeting: 27/09/2011 - Petitions Committee - Fourth Assembly (Item 2)
2 P-04-329 Control of noise nuisance from wind turbines
Supporting documents:
- P-04-329 Control of noise nuisance from wind turbines - cover sheet, item 2 PDF 15 KB View as HTML (2/1) 3 KB
- Additional information provided by the Petitioner, item 2 PDF 89 KB
Minutes:
The Committee considered this petition for the first time.
Actions
The Committee agreed to defer consideration of this issue until the call for evidence closes on 3 November.
The Committee agreed to write to the Chair of the Environment and Sustainability Committee to ask that the petition be considered as part of its inquiry into energy policy and planning.
The Clerking team to provide the Committee with the terms of reference for the Environment and Sustainability Committee’s inquiry into energy policy and planning.